7.8/10 vs Neptune 4 Max's 7/10, and it wins 3 of 5 categories. Buy it for the ecosystem, not the specs. PrusaSlicer, open source, community, and support that's still there in 5 years. Don't buy it if speed or price are your primary metrics: the competition has both covered.
✓ listed for that printer. – not listed, which does not mean it is missing.
Features of the Neptune 4 Max and Prusa MK4S
Neptune 4 Max
Feature
Prusa MK4S
✓Listed
Klipper firmware
–Not listed
✓Listed
Auto bed leveling
✓Listed
✓Listed
Direct drive
–Not listed
✓Listed
PEI build plate
–Not listed
✓Listed
420x420x480mm build
–Not listed
–Not listed
Open source
✓Listed
–Not listed
PrusaSlicer
✓Listed
–Not listed
Nextruder
✓Listed
–Not listed
Input shaping
✓Listed
–Not listed
Ethernet
✓Listed
Scores out of 10
Neptune 4 Max and Prusa MK4S compared: PrintPick scores out of 10
Neptune 4 Max
Spec
Prusa MK4S
9 (wins)
Value
6
5
Beginner Friendliness
8 (wins)
7
Print Quality
9 (wins)
7 (wins)
Speed
6
7
Reliability
10 (wins)
7
Overall
7.8 (wins)
Build space, front view, to one scale
420 × 420 × 480 mm
250 × 210 × 220 mm
What sets these two apart
The widest gap is Value: the Elegoo Neptune 4 Max scores 9 against 6 for the Prusa MK4S, a 3-point lead. The Elegoo Neptune 4 Max has the larger build volume, 420 x 420 x 480mm against 250 x 210 x 220mm, or 633% more space. The Elegoo Neptune 4 Max lists a top speed of 500 mm/s against 200 mm/s.
Pros & Cons
Neptune 4 Max
+420x420x480mm with Klipper: the price-to-volume ratio is hard to beat
+Direct drive on a bed this large is unusual and useful for flexible materials
+Klipper gives you full control to tune speed and acceleration for the mass of this bed
−Open frame at this scale means ABS warping will ruin prints without serious prep
−The sheer footprint means a dedicated table minimum; don't try to share desk space
Prusa MK4S
+Prusa's QC is genuinely better than anyone else's: every printer is test-printed before shipping
+PrusaSlicer is open source and powerful, no subscription, no cloud required
+Customer support answers in hours, not weeks
−200mm/s max is a third of what CoreXY machines do at half the price
−The price for an open-frame bed-slinger is a hard sell in 2025
Buy these with it
A printer does nothing without these. Grab them in the same order.
Is the Elegoo Neptune 4 Max better than the Prusa MK4S?
By the numbers, the Prusa MK4S scores higher (7.8/10). But "better" depends on your use case, the Elegoo Neptune 4 Max may be the smarter buy if you need large-prints.
Which is better for beginners, Elegoo Neptune 4 Max or Prusa MK4S?
The Prusa MK4S is more beginner-friendly (8/10 vs 5/10) with easier setup and a gentler learning curve.
Is the Prusa MK4S worth paying more for over the Elegoo Neptune 4 Max?
The Prusa MK4S scores higher overall (7.8/10 vs 7/10). The extra money gets you prusa's qc is genuinely better than anyone else's: every printer is test-printed before shipping.
What's the main difference between Elegoo Neptune 4 Max and Prusa MK4S?
Build volume (420x420x480mm vs 250x210x220mm) and print speed (500 vs 200 mm/s). The Elegoo Neptune 4 Max is best for large-prints; the Prusa MK4S targets reliability.